Sunday, 24 January 2021

Netaji

 Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose - the name strikes a chord of patriotism which lies buried deep in our sub-conscious somewhere. For our generation and those preceding ours, who were brought up on the staple diet of 26th January and 15th August brand of patriotic fervour he was always an icon, a legend but an enigmatic one. We were simply over awed by his sheer audacity at all levels starting from spurning the ICS to challenging Mahatma Gandhi himself by contesting and winning the Congress presidentship and then relinquishing it. His daring escape from Kolkata house arrest to Kabul is simply unbelievable and part of folklore. If that was not all, his vision in raising the INA and actually leading them in the war effort to rid the nation of the yoke of centuries of colonial rule will catapult him way ahead of his contemporaries in freedom struggle. Mind you that was an era when we had the leaders of the stature of Gandhiji himself Pt Nehru, Sardar Patel, Maulana Azad, Babu Rajendra Prasad,Rajaji each one a luminary in his own right not to forget Bhagat Singh, Azad and countless others who have been venerated by generations of grateful and not so grateful Indians.

But truly apart from Gandhiji it was only Netaji who not only charted a different course but had a following which rivalled that of the Mahatma himself. So much so that even Gandhiji had to literally force him to part ways as his leadership itself was threatened after the loss of his protégé in that landmark election in 1937. Naturally the aura around the man continued to grow even after his mysterious disappearance in the air crash as we were led to believe.

The moot question which Indians asked themselves was "what if Netaji was alive today". In other words they have been convinced all these years that had he been alive, the course of our nation would have been different and definitely better. We Indians have always been idol worshippers and towards this end, we invent gods even when there wasn't one at hand. There are a number of examples in the recent past where mere mortals have been venerated as gods, the host of Godmen past and present and even  Mrs Indira Gandhi in her hey days post 1971 or the PM Modiji fall in the same category. Netaji Bose was that kindle of hope for the masses, he was obviously God like in his demeanour and his persona oozed with a confidence which was rare in a colonised nation. 

He realised rather early, the limitations of the satyagraha model of freedom movement and was prepared to guide the destiny of the nation in his own revolutionary manner. Obviously the power struggle within the Congress Party ensued as the leadership was uncomfortable with a parallel power centre emerging, who had the charisma and aura to motivate and awaken the masses who were still in their slumber. Had he not been eased out of the Congress then, the course of history would have been different, there is no doubt about that. His subsequent forays with the Nazi and fascist regimes were obviously not inspired by their ideology but merely to get them to assist him in driving the British out. He did not kowtow to them but interacted with them as an equal convinced of the justness of the cause.

Netaji was not stuck in any groove, as is evident by his actions in raising the INA and subsequent assault on the British India. While he was inspired by the Socialist ideology, which was true every leader those days, after all, what do you expect from an impoverished colonised nation. Obviously, having been subjected to humiliation, exploitation and deprivation by the Britishers who represented the Capitalist Right and were at its forefront, Indian political leadership had to lean towards the Left. But the remarkable quality of Netaji was his intelligence, understanding the psyche of Indians and his quest for solutions which imbued him with that rare flexibility of mind, where only the cause mattered and the means were secondary. Although it would be a conjecture, but he would definitely have undertaken a course correction much earlier rather than drive us to our doom. 

Most importantly he was the alternative which the nation yearned for, a void which remains unfilled for all these years. 

46 comments:

Ashutosh Tewari said...

Well timed 👍
Sardar n Bose continue to tickle the imagination of many a generations

Glad Gladiator said...

Very nicely put across Suyash!!!

Sheraz Varma said...

Put together with great consciousness. Kudos Suyash. Mitrokhin Archives has details. We all wish he was the chief sculptor of independent undivided India. Alas, he was carved out himself.

KPM Das said...

Good read

Munendra Gupta said...

Netaji is indeed the only alternative the Nation has yearned for, albeit in hindsight. A void never really felt, having been readily filled in by the Nehru-Gandhi family. Great writeup once again Sir 👏

Unknown said...

We are failing and failing as Nation...
Our history and nostalgia takes over every bit of our present and we bask in the glory of past.
We have won few battles.. But what is the present status and lacuna?? Nobody wants to answer.. He would be shunned down as whistle blower or missed the bus or his past will be taken out to curtail the curiosity.
We have become independent and it's quite a time... But what have remained is
Poverty
Power
Water
Roads internal or border..
The mental poverty to consider ours as a poor nation has continued and of course same country has at least a gram of gold in each household....
So why????
Yes because we believe in
Miracles
Leader
Outside county or say super power's....
What we lack is a vision... Vision of a country for next 50 years.....
Shut down all activities...
We don't need award function, inauguration, tv shows, celebrations, festivities.. Games....
Develop our nation first...
Yes in all.... The major problem is our population.. We know, realize... But we don't want to.....

Sudhir Nagpal said...

👍🏼

Pankaj said...

Excellent one once again... keep it up

VM said...

Once again, very aptly penned.
I think, with either Netaji or Sardar being at the helm of affairs, Nation's growth trajectory and character would have been class apart.

Anjan said...

A good introspection.. yes he would have definitely made us a stronger and prouder Nation much earlier.

Col Pankaj Fotedar, VSM (Retd) said...

How true?? Your writing brings out a part of our nations destiny that was not meant to be or was it sabotaged ??

Bisht said...

Your article has brought back the days of pre-independence struggle against the British Raj n also the infighting within Congress which denied a rightful place to Netaji in history.Very apt n timely penned article.Keep it up Suyash.
Bisht

S B Singh said...

An interesting and informative article. Such lucidly you have brought out the prevailing circumstances of the times.
������
Please keep writing.

Pradeep Misra said...

Subhas Chandra Bose: a legend in his lifetime and a myth after death, revered for what imagination wants him to be!!!

Samir Dhaga said...

Nice One...

Kalyan Pitre said...

Well written . He was the a true freedom fighter and the others paled in his aura . That is why there was this concerted conspiracy to change the way Indians view history . The conspiracy was well orchestrated but may unravel if forces that are getting together now prevail ...

Gypsy said...

Very well written Suyash, your write ups are always well timed, you seem to have the pulse of the times !

Bubesh said...

Great one, as always..
A timely and pithy Write up on SC Bose..Thanks

Sunil V Damle said...

Bose was truly a strong visionary. However, the man ended up picking the wrong side in history when he chose to side with the Axis in WWII.

V Pramod Kumar said...

A well timed article Suyash. Well written.

ash kale said...

A well researched, well articulated piece. Lovely read Suyash !!

ash kale said...

A well researched, well articulated piece. Lovely read Suyash !!

Satish Mallik said...

“Netaji was not stuck in any groove ...”. And unfortunately today that is exactly what is happening. Just because Netaji purportedly had differences with Mahatma Gandhi and Pandit Nehru, today he has been grabbed by the party opposing Congress. The left leaning socialist is being elevated by the right wing party just to oppose its political rival. Ironically even our freedom fighters have become victims of party politics. If Pandit Nehru was a protege of Mahatma Gandhi then Netaji was also a protege of Motilal Nehru. Motilal Nehru saw in him what he always wanted to see in Jawaharlal.

Nobody can guarantee for sure what course the nation would have taken had Netaji been at the helm of affairs at the time of independence. However, we always like to believe that what did not happen would have been better than what happened.

Nicely researched and beautifully penned article, Suyash.

raju said...

Nice write up. Thanks for reminding the contributions of Netaji. He remains inspiration for millions of youth. Wish we had some leader of his stature who could demand.... Blood for Freedom, neither such leaders nor such followers. Why his death 8n a plane crash ? remains a mystery and is yet to be deciphered , and if he survived then what made him remain in hiding is a even bigger mystery. Hope some day ,some authentic version will come to light. Beautifully penned . Thanks, keep it up.

arun sharma said...

Definitely a thought provoking write up, Suyash. Enjoyed reading it. Let's hope his legacy is not usurped by lumpen elements with divisive ideologies now.

Madhavi V Mhatre said...

Nice write up 👌👌
The aura and spirit of Netaji Subhash Chandra remains inspiration for youth even today. 🙏🙏
Need such leaders in today’s time. 🇮🇳🇮🇳

Unknown said...

Couldn't agree more... Netaji's ways & vision were definitely a challenge for the then so called power blocks. The mystical way in which he disappeared could never be justifiable enough.
Very well written.👏👌

Surbhi said...

Couldn't agree more... Netaji's ways & vision were definitely a challenge for the then so called power blocks. The mystical way in which he disappeared could never be justifiable enough.
Very well written.����

Shirin Deshpande said...

After dabbling in subtle humour, you have made a mark with key topics occupying current mind spaces, and throwing up an alternate path by way of well researched & crisp jottings like this one... obviously, you intend tickling the sleepy grey ones in another and sir, you sure do it well. Like they say, sharing info is one thing, but waking up another to start thinking is totally another level. You sure trigger it all sir! Pleasure to see this Avatar!

Unknown said...

Very well written and completely agree our tendency to "godify" anyone who seems even remotely unaffected by self interest.

Unknown said...

Well written about our " Legendary revolutionary leader". A good read.

Sofie said...

Welcome...to a road less travelled!

Raj Jagga said...

Even Mahatma got worried...that was the charisma of Netaji....most Indians look towards others to solve their problems..huge population! Well articulated.

Abhi said...

Very well articulated, Sir.

Abhi said...

Very well articulated Sir. A legend.

Sengar said...

Very timely, very apt and comprehensive .

Anil Kumar said...

Remembering Netaji… thanks for presenting a far-sight into his visions for India. Had he been successful, I am sure many of the lingering issues of this nation would have absent

Anonymous said...

Jai Hind...Jai Hind ki Sena

MuksIaf said...

Very well written sir. You leave the reader wondering What If???
Just to add two little known facts.

1. Netaji was the first independent head of state of independent India in 1943, that was recognized by other countries. The Azad Hind Govt in Andamans.

2. There is no record of any plane crash in any airport of Taiwan on 18th Aug 1945. There is infact evidence to suggest that the ashes preserved at Renkoji temple in Japan are that of a Japanese soldier named Tanaka.

Danny said...

Every 'freedom fighter' had his own motivation and not all of it would perhaps be described as patriotic to the India of our perception today. Again, each had his own route map and compass.

Would his alliance with the Japs have brought us freedom in a counterfactual world? Experience of others during the war would prove otherwise. Indeed, the harrowing experience of states in the neighborhood who had been occupied by the Japanese before WW-II was well known. How then did he plan to deal with them once his mission was accomplished?

Anonymous said...

Well written Suyash, very timely too on his birth anniversary. “ What ifs” will always remain. That’s what history does to us. Salute the legend and your write up.
Nandan

Raj Jagga said...

Always a pleasure to read your jottings. This one is patriotic.
Netaji was a personality which probably even Gandhi ji feared; however respect for Gandhi ji made this colossal resign as Congress President.
There is no doubt that course India followed would have been different under him or Sardar Patel . We as Indians should not lament but work towards greatness. The problem with most of us Indians is that kaam karna nahi,rona dhona jyada hai. Things will change for better and that is my eternal hope.
Once again Suyesh..great reading.

Anonymous said...

Sir ,
Thought provoking, it struck me like a bolt,the etymology of the word Neta - a leader , a person who puts no bars on hold for the national cause.
In contrast to 'nahi tha' ( absent) when the nation needs him or her.
How things get corrupted ! Or should we say it is the 'khurrapaath' of strife less times.

Anonymous said...

Regards Karthik

Dharam Vir Tomar said...

Suyash,
Very nicely put forward the true facts. We lost the legendary man at a very wrong time, a great loss to the nation.

Anonymous said...

Well written sir